Tisha's, Cape May, NJ:
A Restaurant Review
Tisha's Restaurant
322 Washington Street Mall
Cape May, NJ
Tishas Restaurant Highlights
Fare: New American - Italian influenced
Price: Expensive
Food Quality: Well executed menu, artfully presented dishes.
Service: Friendly, efficient.
Ambiance/Decor: Upscale, contemporary beach town decor.
Overall Rating: 2 1/2 Stars
Note: Four-star Rating System from 1/2 star = poor to Four stars = Best in Class
Recommended For: Diners who enjoy a well prepared, inspirational American menu.
Not Recommended For: Budget conscious diners who prefer a less pricey, more casual family atmosphere and menu.
Recommended dishes: When available, The Filet Au Poivre; The Chilean Sea bass; and The Jumbo Shrimp Puttanesca
Alcohol: BYOB
Located in the heart of historic Cape May, Tisha’s is a culinary treasure that effortlessly combines fine dining with the relaxed charm of a seaside town.
Situated on the bustling Washington Street Mall, this family-run bistro has long been a beloved local favorite—and with good reason.
From the moment you walk through the doors, Tisha’s exudes an inviting blend of elegance and warmth. The intimate dining room features tasteful décor, while the outdoor seating offers a front-row seat to lively pedestrian activity, complemented by the refreshing ocean breeze.
The ambiance reflects a sophisticated coastal vibe, with seascape photographs adorning the walls, wooden floors lending a timeless touch, and tables thoughtfully set with linen napkins.
Owners and Chef Paul Negro, along with his wife Jennifer, curate a seasonally inspired menu that showcases fresh, thoughtfully crafted dishes.
The menu offers a delightful fusion of American cuisine with Italian influences, all built upon locally sourced ingredients, ensuring every dish is rich in flavor and quality.
Service at Tisha’s is warm, attentive, and knowledgeable without being intrusive. Staff members take pride in crafting a memorable experience, and in accommodating dietary preferences.
While prices lean toward the higher end, the quality, service, and atmosphere make it well worth the indulgence.
Ideal for romantic dinners, special occasions, or simply an upscale dining experience in a relaxed beach town setting, Tisha’s consistently delivers an unforgettable meal.
Outdoor seating is available along the pedestrian mall, providing a charming al fresco option.
Not suited for young children. Parking can be limited during peak summer evenings, so arriving early is advised.
Tisha’s remains open year-round, with hours and days varying seasonally.
(Updated: April 2025)
Our Restaurant Rating Criteria to Ensure Minimum Subjective Evaluation
