Tim McLoone's Supper Club, Asbury Park, NJ:
A Restaurant Review
Tim McLoone's Supper Club
1200 Ocean Avenue
Asbury Park, NJ
Tim Mcloone's Supper Club; Restaurant Highlights
Fare: New American
Price: Expensive
Food Quality: Fair, compared to other high end Asbury Park restaurants.
Service: Fair
Decor: Attractive decor with an "Old World" style supper club ambiance, and scenic beach front ocean views
Overall Rating: 2 Stars
Note: Four star Rating System from 1/2 Star = Poor to Four stars = Best in Class
Noise Level: Moderate - High
Dress: Casual
Recommended For: Older diners who enjoy an "Old World" supper club experience
Not Recommended For: Millennials who enjoy contemporary entertainment or budget conscious diners who prefer heavy sauce food preparations served in large portions.
Recommended dishes: When available, The Dry Aged Beef Filet with spinach, black truffle butter, and crispy mashed potato; and The NJ Caught Mahi Mahi with haricot verts, mashed potato, lemon sauce, and tomato comfit.
Liquor: Full Bar service
Tim Mcloone’s Supper Club is one of the many Tim McLoone restaurants in New Jersey and Maryland National Harbor. This Asbury Park boardwalk popular dining spot is close to three of Mcloone's other Asbury Park boardwalk restaurants: The Iron Whale, Robinson's Ale House, and the latest addition, the AP Rooftop.
Tim Mcloone's Supper Club, located on the boardwalk beachfront, upstairs from Robinson's Ale House, is an upscale theatre in the round restaurant and supper club with live music reminiscent of the popular clubs in New York in the 1930s and '40s.
It's best enjoyed by people who enjoy dining and dancing and shows by performers that appeal to the 50+ crowd
In warmer months, lunch and dinner patrons can sit on the balcony with an excellent ocean view.
The food is satisfactory, lacking creativity and inspiration. The menu features comfort food, and entrees of seafood, meats, and pasta with a few choices of vegan and gluten-free items.
As a music venue, it is excellent with a good sound mix, and video screens of the band playing, though depending on the band the sound can be very high, and for conversation you may have to shout of the sound of the music.
The seating is up front close to the stage. However, tables are packed close together.
The restaurant is open for lunch and dinner, seven days/week.
They are open for New Year's Eve and offer a four-course prix fixe menu, which also includes party favors and a complimentary champagne toast at midnight.
(updated: September 2024)
How Do We Review (analyze) Restaurants?
New Jersey Leisure Guide strives to provide analytic restaurant reviews.
The methodology used is research, analysis driven --- as opposed to that of a single restaurant critic or a social media platform, viewer comment posting board.
Guide to Dining in The Asbury Park, NJ area: A culinary adventure!
Discover the dining reviews of Asbury Park NJ and the the neighboring towns of Allenhurst, Bradley Beach, Neptune, and Ocean Grove.
Asbury Park NJ Visitors Guide!
A Vibrant Jersey Shore town with a nationally recognized music scene, beautiful beach, downtown and boardwalk dining, downtown shops and art galleries.
Guide to Belmar NJ area Restaurants with dining reviews. Discover the restaurants in Belmar and the neighboring towns of Avon By The Sea, Spring Lake, and Sea Girt.
Experience the Ultimate Night Clubs and Dance Venues in New Jersey.
Discover The Best NJ clubs with live bands, DJ's, dancing, and some with top notch dining.