Proving Ground, Highlands, NJ: A Restaurant Review

The Proving Ground restaurant stands as one of New Jersey's premier waterfront dining spots.

With breathtaking views of the water and sunsets, the ambiance alone would make it worth a visit, even if the food weren't as excellent as it is. But rest assured, the food is fantastic, and you'll be telling all your friends to check it out.

While the stunning waterfront views might steal the show, the interior dining areas hold their own with a lively pub and sports bar vibe, complete with plenty of TVs. The restaurant features three bars: one upstairs, one downstairs, and a seasonal outdoor Patio Bar during the warmer months.

Live entertainment is a year-round feature, adding to the vibrant atmosphere. When the weather’s nice, you can enjoy outdoor dining on the expansive deck overlooking the water. During the cooler months, some tables are equipped with built-in flame pits, and there are gas-fired patio heaters placed throughout to keep things cozy.

For the best experience, request a window table in the upstairs dining area, or, in warmer months, a spot on the outdoor deck to really soak in the surroundings.

The menu, which changes with the seasons, focuses on fresh, flavorful seafood. It also draws inspiration from the area’s history, with a military theme inspired by the former Sandy Hook base that tested artillery.

For boaters, there’s convenient dock and dine access with a boat landing for easy docking.

The restaurant is kid-friendly, with a dedicated kids' menu, and valet parking is available. While there is nearby non-valet parking, it can be limited.

Open six days a week for lunch and dinner, The Proving Ground is closed on Mondays but offers a delightful brunch on Sundays.

(Updated: February 2025)