Panico's Bistro,  Cape May, NJ: A Restaurant Review

Just minutes from downtown Cape May, Panico’s Bistro is a high-end, BYOB pizza restaurant beloved by locals. Housed in a beautifully restored old church, it offers expertly crafted brick oven pizza alongside an extensive menu of Italian dishes, many with a Mediterranean twist.

During the vacation season, Panico’s is a favorite among families and pizza lovers seeking some of the best slices in Cape May. Generous portions and a warm, welcoming atmosphere make it a go-to dining spot.

The interior is bright and spacious, featuring high ceilings, huge windows, ceiling fans, and hardwood floors. At the heart of the dining room, a large wood-burning brick oven adds to the charm, while tablecloth-draped tables, cloth napkins, and soft background music create a relaxed bistro-style ambiance—though on busy weekends, the lively chatter of diners takes center stage.

Every meal starts with a complimentary serving of homemade garlic bread and dipping oil, setting the tone for a delicious experience. The signature brick-oven, thin-crust pizza is perfectly charred and crunchy (without being cracker-like), sturdy enough to hold its generous toppings without flopping. A wide selection of toppings allows for endless customization.

Beyond pizza, Panico’s Bistro boasts a diverse menu of Italian entrées, including pasta, chicken, shrimp, seafood, and steak dishes.

With ample on-site parking, your visit is hassle-free.

Panico’s is open year-round with seasonal hours. During the summer, they serve dinner seven nights a week starting at 5 PM.

(Updated: February 2025)