Mustache Bills Diner, Barnegat Light, NJ:
A Restaurant Review
Mustache Bills Diner
Eighth Avenue and Broadway
Barnegat Light, NJ
Restaurant Highlights
Fare: American-Diner
Price: In-Expensive
Decor: Classic old school diner
Recommended For: Diners who enjoy traditional diner food, in a classic diner setting.
Not Recommended For: Diners who prefer a high end, eclectic breakfast menu
Nestled on the northern tip of Long Beach Island, just a few blocks from the iconic Barnegat Lighthouse, Mustache Bill's is a beloved, affordable dining spot cherished by both the local fishing community and seasonal vacationers.
This quintessential Jersey diner, with its charming 1950s vibe, features green swivel stools at the counter and cozy booths along the walls, offering a nostalgic atmosphere that feels like stepping back in time.
Owned by Bill Smith, who began his journey as a teenage dishwasher and took over the diner in 1972, Mustache Bill's exudes a warm, down-home friendliness.
The food is consistently well-prepared, reasonably priced, and has earned the diner the prestigious "America's Classics" award from the James Beard Foundation, a testament to its authentic, comforting appeal.
If you're in the Long Beach Island area and craving a hearty breakfast or lunch, Mustache Bill's is a must-visit. Their pancakes and omelets are particularly standout dishes. The Three-Egg Omelet, available with a wide array of ingredient choices, is a crowd favorite.
For something truly special, try the Potato Skin Omelet, loaded with home fries, cheddar cheese, bacon, scallions, and sour cream, or the Crab, Mushroom, and Cheese Omelet, packed with generous chunks of local blue-claw crab meat and served with creamy grits.
Mustache Bill's operates on a seasonal schedule, open Friday through Sunday from 6 AM to 3 PM during September, October, November, March, April, May, and June. It shifts to daily service in July and August but remains closed during the winter months of December, January, and February.
Be prepared for a wait during the busy summer season, as this local gem draws quite the crowd.
(Updated: October 2024)
Our Restaurant Rating Criteria to Ensure Minimum Subjective Evaluation
