Long Beach Island New Jersey: Restaurants With Reviews

Restaurant reviews of Long Beach Island, NJ popular restaurants

Long Beach Island Restaurants: Reviews of Popular Dining Spots

Long Beach Island (LBI) offers a diverse and exciting dining scene, catering to every taste—from oceanfront fine dining to casual beachside eateries and fresh, locally sourced seafood. Whether you're craving an elegant dinner, a laid-back lunch, or a quick bite after a day on the water, LBI’s restaurant scene has something for everyone.

A Jersey Shore Dining Destination

As a beloved summer vacation spot, LBI is known for its stunning coastal beauty, majestic summer homes, and lively beachfront atmosphere. With 18 miles of pristine beaches, abundant fishing and boating opportunities, and thrilling activities like parasailing, the island is a paradise for outdoor enthusiasts and food lovers alike.

A Culinary Mix: Casual & Fine Dining

LBI offers a wide selection of family-friendly casual dining restaurants, perfect for enjoying a relaxed meal after a day at the shore. While fine dining options are fewer, they provide exceptional gourmet experiences, often featuring locally sourced seafood, handcrafted dishes, and intimate atmospheres.

Whether you're visiting for a weekend getaway or an extended summer stay, Long Beach Island’s restaurants provide a taste of the Jersey Shore’s best flavors. Plan ahead, make reservations when needed, and savor the culinary delights of LBI!

Black Eyed Susans Restaurant. LBI, New Jersey

 Black Eyed Susan's
Whether you're savoring a beautifully plated seasonal dish or enjoying the breathtaking sunset, Black Eyed Susans promises a top-tier dining experience in LBI.
Nestled near Barnegat Bay, the restaurant features a simple yet elegant décor.The menu emphasizes locally sourced ingredients whenever possible, supplemented by organically raised meats, dairy, eggs, fruits, and vegetables.

Engleside Inn Restaurant, LBI, NJ

 Engleside Inn - Leeward Room
Nestled along the oceanfront, The Engleside Inn's Leeward Room stands out as one of Long Beach Island's premier fine dining destinations.
Renowned as the "go-to" spot in LBI for celebrating special occasions with family and friends, it is also celebrated for offering the best sushi on the island.
The menu highlights traditional American cuisine, showcasing expertly prepared dishes such as fresh-caught seafood, premium steaks, pasta, chicken, lamb, and pork

Gables Restaurant, LBI, NJ

 Gables
The Gables Restaurant is housed in a beautifully restored circa-1900 Victorian B&B, making it one of the most upscale and romantic dining destinations in Long Beach Island. With its refined atmosphere and gourmet cuisine, it's the perfect place for an intimate dinner—especially when paired with an overnight stay.
The Gables offers an exclusive Three-Course Prix Fixe Menu, featuring a carefully curated selection of dishes made from the finest ingredients.

Tuskers Tavern, LBI, NJ

Tuckers Tavern
Located by the bay in Beach Haven, Tucker's Tavern is one of the most vibrant summer destinations, offering a winning combination of quality pub fare, craft beers, and a charming rustic, nautical ambiance. The gastropub menu is as eclectic as the atmosphere, with a fully covered deck boasting some of the best bay views, and the Buoy Bar, a rooftop bar, offers stunning panoramic vistas—especially breathtaking at sunset.

Mustache Bills Diner, LBI, NJ

 Mustache Bill's
Nestled on the northern tip of Long Beach Island, just a few blocks from the iconic Barnegat Lighthouse, Mustache Bill's is a classic affordable dining spot cherished by both the local fishing community and seasonal vacationers.


Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs):
Dining on Long Beach Island, NJ

Question
What types of restaurants can I find on Long Beach Island?

Answer

LBI offers a diverse dining scene, including:

  • Seafood Restaurants – Fresh, locally sourced fish, shellfish, and raw bars.
  • Fine Dining – Upscale bistros and steakhouses with gourmet menus.
  • Casual Eateries – Beachside cafés, diners, and burger joints.
  • Italian Cuisine – Handmade pasta, wood-fired pizzas, and classic Italian dishes.
  • American & Comfort Food – BBQ, burgers, and hearty entrees.
  • Asian & Fusion – Sushi, Thai, and globally inspired flavors.
  • Vegetarian & Vegan – Plant-based options and farm-to-table cuisine.
  • Breakfast & Brunch Spots – Pancakes, omelets, and artisanal coffee shops.

Question
How much does dining out on LBI typically cost?

Answer

Dining prices vary by restaurant type:

  • Casual dining & takeout – $15–$25 per person
  • Mid-range restaurants – $25–$45 per person
  • Fine dining & upscale bistros – $55+ per person

Prices fluctuate based on seafood selections, seasonal specials, and location. Reservations for high-end restaurants are strongly recommended, especially in summer.

Question
What is the ambiance like at LBI restaurants?

Answer

Restaurants on LBI range from laid-back beachside eateries to elegant fine dining experiences:

  • Romantic & Upscale – Candlelit tables, fireplaces, and refined settings.
  • Casual & Family-Friendly – Relaxed atmospheres with outdoor seating.
  • Waterfront & Scenic Views – Restaurants overlooking Barnegat Bay or the Atlantic Ocean.
  • Lively & Social – Bars, pubs, and music-filled venues with an energetic vibe.

Many restaurants feature outdoor seating, especially during summer, offering sunset views and ocean breezes.

Question
Is parking available at LBI restaurants?

Answer

  • Many restaurants offer free on-site parking or small private lots.
  • Street parking is common, but spots fill up quickly in peak season.
  • Some high-traffic areas, like Beach Haven and Ship Bottom, have metered or permit parking.
  • If parking is limited, consider biking or walking in town centers.

Question
When is the best time to visit LBI restaurants?

Answer

  • Summer (June–August) – Expect long wait times, especially on weekends. Reservations are strongly recommended.
  • Spring & Fall (April–May, September–October) – Fewer crowds, pleasant weather, and seasonal menus.
  • Winter (November–March) – Some restaurants close for the season, but select spots remain open on weekends or for special events.

Question
Are there takeout and delivery options?

Answer
Yes! Many restaurants offer takeout, curbside pickup, and limited delivery. Some popular seafood markets and delis also provide fresh meals to-go, perfect for beachside picnics.

How We Review Restaurants?

Our Restaurant Rating Criteria to Ensure Minimum Subjective Evaluation