Cape May New Jersey Restaurants With Dining Reviews

410 Bank Street Restaurant 
410 Bank St is a hidden gem in Cape May’s charming downtown, offering an intimate, romantic vibe perfect for date nights or special occasions. Housed in a quaint Victorian building, diners are about to experience an attractive tropical setting with a charming walkway that takes you under cover of overhanging of wisteria vines towards the restored 1840 Victorian carriage house with spinning fans and trimmed dining rooms. They serve a well-executed, inspirational menu shines with a fusion of Louisiana French, Caribbean and Asian culinary and smoking techniques, prepared with fresh local produce and locally caught seafood.

Backstreet Cafe 
Nestled in West Cape May, the Backstreet Cafe stands as a cherished alternative to the area's many fine dining establishments. 
Beloved by locals and returning tourists alike, it delivers high-quality cuisine at reasonable prices in a relaxed, unpretentious setting.

Blue Pig Tavern 
The Blue Pig Tavern offers a charming and nostalgic dining experience, centered around a farm-to-table philosophy. Featuring fresh, seasonal ingredients sourced from Cape May’s own Beach Plum Farm, the menu highlights hearty, modern American fare with a local touch. Nestled within historic Congress Hall, the Tavern has deep roots dating back to the 1800s, when it served as a gathering place for whalers. Today, it retains that warm, welcoming spirit, with cozy interiors and rustic charm spread across several dining spaces.

Cape May Fish Market 
The Cape May Fish Market is an excellent choice for visitors to the Washington Street Mall who want quality seafood in a relaxed, no-frills atmosphere for lunch or dinner. The ambiance is modern and clean, featuring high-backed wooden booths lit by candles and walls adorned with vintage photographs of the historic concrete ships built near the end of the war, now resting off the coast of Cape May Point.
During warmer months, guests can enjoy outdoor dining on the pedestrian mall. If you're visiting during the summer, consider requesting outdoor seating to take in the lively atmosphere and indulge in some people-watching.

Cold Spring Grange 
The Cold Spring Grange Restaurant, situated adjacent to Cold Spring Brewery at Historic Cold Spring Village, operates within a historic 1912 Colonial Revival building listed on both the National and New Jersey Registers of Historic Places, is one of Cape May's top farm-to-table dining destinations. The menu features expertly prepared dishes made with fresh, locally sourced ingredients, much of it from Cold Spring farms.

Cricket Club
The Cricket Club, located on the former site of the iconic Merion Inn, opened its doors in 2022 and has since joined the ranks of Cape May’s top fine-dining destinations. The restaurant has undergone a complete renovation, with a newly designed interior that blends traditional charm with modern elegance. Warm lighting and thoughtful details create a welcoming and stylish ambiance. The Contemporary American menu is creative, well-executed, and reasonably priced. In addition to full-sized entrées, guests can choose from a selection of thoughtfully prepared lighter fare.

C- View Inn 
Nestled near the bay, the C-View Inn is a beloved local hangout and a hidden gem for visitors seeking hearty, affordable bar food in a laid-back, family-friendly tavern setting. Known as Cape May’s oldest and friendliest tavern, the C-View has been serving up comfort food for over a century. The atmosphere is nostalgically divey—but in a cool, unpretentious way. It's far less touristy than many other spots in Cape May and remains a go-to for locals

Ebbitt Room Restaurant 
Nestled within the historic Virginia Hotel, a Victorian gem dating to 1879, The Ebbitt Room stands as a premier destination for fine dining and romance in Cape May. They offer curated menu rooted in seasonal, organic ingredients. Beyond the plate, The Ebbitt Room boasts a sophisticated bar and fireplace lounge, ideal for savoring artisanal cocktails or post-dinner drinks. In warmer months, the ambiance shifts to breezy al fresco dining on the porch or garden patio.

E.M. Hemingway's at The Grand Hotel
E.M. Hemingway’s Restaurant, located inside the Grand Hotel and just steps from the beach, draws visitors looking for upscale dining with ocean views, classic steaks, and cocktails.
The bar at Hemingway’s has a loyal following, particularly among Philadelphia sports fans. With six high-definition TVs airing everything from NFL Sunday Ticket and MLB Extra Innings to the Big Ten Network and Comcast Sportsnet Philadelphia, it’s a go-to spot for catching the game.

Exit Zero Filling Station
Exit Zero Filling Station stands out as one of Cape May’s most distinctive success stories—a vibrant destination offering a creatively crafted casual menu, full bar service, and a warm, welcoming atmosphere. This one-of-a-kind spot combines a restaurant and bar with a quirky gift shop selling Cape May-themed apparel and an actual working gas station.
Open year round, in the summer, the fun spills outdoors, where guests can dine under the gas station canopy alongside vintage pumps while enjoying live music. Winter brings its own charm, with seven cozy tents converted into intimate outdoor dining spaces for groups of 5–6.
For an unforgettable dining experience, book the heated 1956 Airstream Bubble, a retro-inspired private trailer complete with a record player spinning classic hits from the ‘50s and ‘60s. It's the ultimate throwback atmosphere for a special night out.

Fins Bar and Grille 
Fins Bar & Grille stands out from the typical "historic" Cape May eateries and local taverns. Despite what the name might suggest, this isn't your average bar-and-grill experience. Instead, you'll find a broad, diner-style menu packed with comfort food favorites—think burgers, sandwiches, tacos, seafood, and more—at approachable prices. Inside, the vibe is trendy and modern. The bar area features a stunning blue wave-lit glass bar, high-back chairs, and an eye-catching saltwater fish tank. The dining room includes a cozy fireplace, perfect for a romantic meal—especially in the cooler off-season. 

Freda's Cafe and Deli
Freda’s Cafe is an intimate, 12-table gem tucked away in Cape May, offering a unique, eclectic dining experience that stands out against the town’s classic Victorian charm. With the ambiance of a cozy European bistro, it provides a cosmopolitan twist in a historic setting.
Fresh seafood is a standout on the menu, often paired with gourmet sides like flavorful portobello rice pilaf or creamy garlic mashed potatoes.
The decor is understated, creating a quaint café feel with soft lighting and closely set tables that enhance the intimate vibe. One caveat: restroom access requires a key and a short walk outside to a side entrance.

George's Place 
Nestled in the heart of Cape May’s historic district, George’s Place offers a cozy, beginning to morning comfort food, with a focus on generous portions and Jersey-fresh ingredients.
A stone’s throw from the beach and Victorian bed-and-breakfasts, they have been a local institution for decades, celebrated for its hearty breakfasts, friendly service, and unpretentious seaside charm.

Good Earth Organic Eatery
Good Earth Organic Eatery is Cape May’s only 100% organic restaurant, and a hidden gem for those seeking fresh, wholesome food. This unassuming, counter-service café draws in health-conscious diners, vegetarians, and curious carnivores alike with its thoughtful, seasonal menu of Italian-inspired vegan and seafood dishes.

Grana BYOB 
Grana BYOB is widely regarded as one of the premier gourmet dining experiences in Cape May, offering a thoughtfully crafted "Modern American" menu that combines creativity with culinary precision. 
Guests can choose from à la carte offerings or indulge in a curated Chef’s Tasting Prix Fixe Four-Course Menu. Options for vegan, vegetarian, and gluten-free diners are also available, ensuring a welcoming experience for all.

Hot Dog Tommy's 
Hot Dog Tommy’s isn’t just a food stand—it’s a local legend. Where else but Cape May would you find a guy in a floppy hot dog hat serving up top-notch dogs and bottom-tier jokes. And somehow, it fits perfectly into this otherwise refined seaside town. 

Iccara Italian Bistro 
Iccara Italian Bistro, located just steps from the Washington Street Mall in Cape May, ranks among the town's top BYOB Italian dining spots. It features a carefully curated menu served in a chic, modern atmosphere. Iccara is family-friendly, with a dedicated kids’ menu, and convenient parking is available nearby at Washington Commons with a discounted fee. 

Louisa's Cafe 
Tucked just off the Washington Street Pedestrian Mall, Louisa's Cafe is a cozy, 20-seat gem that serves thoughtfully prepared, wholesome food in a delightfully quirky setting. 
The decor leans charmingly offbeat: mismatched dishes, plain paper napkins, and a tight space that trades polish for personality. Forget printed menus—everything is scrawled on a blackboard or shared by the warm, attentive staff. 
The ever-changing menu highlights local and regional fare, featuring wild-caught fish from the Atlantic and Delaware Bay, and produce from Beach Plum Farm and nearby New Jersey farms. You won’t find red meat or sugary confections here—just fresh, flavorful, feel-good food. 

Lucky Bones Backwater Grille 
Lucky Bones Backwater Grille perfectly captures the laid-back, coastal charm that defines Cape May.
A standout among Cape May’s casual dining options, Lucky Bones is known for delivering consistently delicious meals that appeal to all ages, making it a favorite for families and locals alike. The restaurant features rustic decor with a cozy, energetic vibe—though it can get quite lively and noisy during peak hours. Health-conscious diners will appreciate the menu’s commitment to zero trans fats and in-house desserts crafted to reduce unhealthy fat without sacrificing flavor.

Maison Bleue Bistro 
Maison Bleue, nestled within the Hugh Bed and Breakfast, is a charming French bistro that offers a modern, stylish take on the classic French dining experience. It's a delightful blend of flair, sophistication, and intimacy—a welcome breath of fresh air in a town whose culinary scene tends to cater to popular American tastes. 
The menu celebrates the essence of French cuisine—classic techniques, executed with simplicity and a focus on high-quality ingredients. 

McGlades Restaurant 
You can’t get any closer to the ocean than McGlade’s.
Located right on the beach—just behind Morrow’s Nut House on the boardwalk—McGlade’s offers a front-row seat to the sea. Enjoy breakfast on the deck with the ocean at your feet and maybe even spot dolphins gliding along the shore. 

Oyster Bay Restaurant 
Oyster Bay Bar & Restaurant is a well-loved spot in Cape May, offering a blend of classic American cuisine and a fully stocked bar.
The interior has a retro, '70s steakhouse vibe, featuring three nautical-themed dining rooms decorated with murals and maritime photos. The recently renovated bar area is lively and welcoming, complemented by a top-notch bar staff and a strong selection of wines and martinis. 

Panico's Bistro 
Just minutes from downtown Cape May, Panico’s Bistro is a high-end, BYOB pizza restaurant beloved by locals. Housed in a beautifully restored old church, it offers expertly crafted brick oven pizza alongside an extensive menu of Italian dishes, many with a Mediterranean twist. During the vacation season, Panico’s is a favorite among families and pizza lovers seeking some of the best slices in Cape May. Generous portions and a warm, welcoming atmosphere make it a go-to dining spot.

Peter Shields Inn Restaurant 
The Peter Shields Inn offers an elegant fine dining experience within a beautifully restored Georgian Revival estate, steps from the oceanfront in Cape May. Blending historic charm with contemporary sophistication, the inn attracts guests seeking a romantic ambiance marked by candlelit tables, polished service, and a touch of old-world refinement. In warmer months, the oceanfront front porch provides serene views.

Primal By Mia 
Primal By Mia is widely regarded as one of Cape May’s premier dining destinations.
Setting itself apart from other upscale restaurants in the area, Primal By Mia is known for serving the finest dry-aged steaks south of Atlantic City. It's also the only high-end dining establishment in Cape May located directly on the beach, with every seat offering breathtaking ocean views. The kitchen focused on a high-end, creatively curated menu featuring top-quality ingredients. While the menu is intentionally limited, it includes standout offerings like dry-aged Wagyu and tomahawk steaks. The restaurant’s ambiance is chic yet relaxed, with a stylish, beach-inspired decor.

Quincy's Lobster Rolls
Quincy’s brings the flavors of Maine straight to the Jersey Shore with a fast-casual twist. Specializing in fresh Maine lobster, they offer generous portions at reasonable prices, with limited indoor and outdoor seating available.
Their take on the classic New England lobster roll features tender lobster dressed with a touch of mayo and a drizzle of butter, served alongside Cape Cod chips and a pickle. For a lighter option, try the no-carb lobster roll—lobster wrapped in crisp baby romaine leaves instead of a traditional bun.

Sapore Italiano 
Sapore Italiano is a fine dining, white-tablecloth restaurant offering traditional Italian cuisine in a beautifully restored Victorian home. With its charming "Old World" ambiance, the setting creates a warm and elegant dining experience.
The menu features classic, homemade Italian dishes crafted with fresh, farm-to-table ingredients sourced from local farms. Many of the pastas are made in-house. The restaurant spans two floors and offers seven intimate dining rooms, including one with a cozy fireplace and elegant mantle.

Sea Salt Restaurant 
Sea Salt, located within the Ocean Club Hotel in Cape May’s quieter north end, offers a casually elegant fine dining experience with a modern, trendy flair. Overlooking the ocean, it fills a unique niche in the local dining scene. 
The interior exudes beach-chic style, with a vibrant bar, dark wood furnishings, silver-blue walls, white-linen tables, and soft candlelight. Large windows open to an outdoor patio during warmer months, creating a breezy, inviting atmosphere. 
They serve a thoughtfully crafted menu that highlights locally sourced seafood and seasonal produce.

 Secondo 
Secondo is a favorite among those seeking a fresh alternative to Cape May’s traditional dining scene, Secondo delivers a stylish, laid-back experience with an urban vibe and waterfront views. In the warmer months, guests can enjoy outdoor dining on the covered patio, which overlooks the harbor. The patio’s standout feature is a long, rectangular fire pit that adds ambiance and warmth to the waterfront setting. The menu leans Mediterranean, with a focus on Italian and Greek-inspired seafood dishes. Expect a variety of creatively prepared entrées and daily specials, along with a bar menu that includes their signature brick oven pizzas.

The Lobster House Restaurant 
The Lobster House is Cape May’s largest and most iconic waterfront restaurant, known for its fresh, locally caught seafood served daily at moderate prices. A longstanding favorite among tourists, it’s especially popular with families and large groups.
It boasts a charming nautical ambiance across five spacious dining rooms, a lively bar, a year-round fish market, a cozy coffee shop, and a seasonal outdoor raw bar. One of its most unique features is the Schooner American—a 130-foot authentic Grand Banks sailing vessel docked beside the restaurant, serving as an outdoor cocktail lounge during the summer months. Guests can enjoy a full bar, light lunch options, and evening appetizers while taking in the waterfront views.

The Mad Batter 
Perched in the heart of Cape May’s historic district, The Mad Batter Restaurant is a vibrant, eclectic gem -- a Cape May classic that has been delighting diners since 1976.
Housed within the charming Carroll Villa Hotel, this family-owned institution blends Victorian charm with a dash of bohemian flair, offering a breakfast and brunch experience as colorful as its famed orange-and-purple exterior.
Brunch reigns supreme here, with dishes that balance indulgence and innovation. They specialize in creative combinations of fresh ingredients. On summer mornings, get there early or prepared to wait in line for breakfast. 

Vintage BYOB 
Vintage BYOB is an upscale, open-air restaurant nestled within the picturesque gardens of the historic Emlen Physick Estate. Known for its charming and intimate outdoor setting, Vintage offers a thoughtfully crafted and inspiring menu. While the dining experience is entirely outdoors, guests can enjoy their meals year-round in a climate-controlled, weatherproof tent, ensuring comfort in any season. The menu highlights locally sourced ingredients, bringing vibrant flavors and refined presentations to the table.
Dining at Vintage feels special—from the string-lit garden ambiance to the elegantly set tables draped in dark linen, complete with candlelight, linen napkins, and fine china.

The Washington Inn 
The Washington Inn & Wine Bar — a historic gem in Cape May — has earned its reputation as one of the area’s premier fine dining destinations. Originally built in 1840 as a plantation home, this landmark restaurant exudes timeless charm and elegance. Ideal for celebrating special occasions or hosting a refined power dinner, The Washington Inn offers an old-world dining experience with a well-executed traditional menu, an extensive wine list, and the nostalgic ambiance of soft background music. The kitchen consistently delivers well-prepared, high-quality dishes that emphasizes seasonal menus tailored to complement the Washington Inn's emphasis on rare and sustainable wines.

The yb (Younger Brother) Restaurant 
The yb in Cape May, NJ offers a fresh, modern Mediterranean twist on contemporary American cuisine, served in a cozy, stylish setting. The yb stands out as one of Cape May’s top dining destinations—offering thoughtfully crafted, flavor-packed dishes at prices that are surprisingly affordable for the area. The limited menu is a curated selection of New American dishes, heavily inspired by Mediterranean flavors.

Tisha's Restaurant 
Located in the heart of historic Cape May, Tisha’s is a culinary treasure that effortlessly combines fine dining with the relaxed charm of a seaside town.
The intimate dining room features tasteful décor, while the outdoor seating offers a front-row seat to lively pedestrian activity, complemented by the refreshing ocean breeze.

The menu offers a delightful fusion of American cuisine with Italian influences, all built upon locally sourced ingredients, ensuring every dish is rich in flavor and quality.

Ugly Mug Tavern
The Ugly Mug is a popular local hangout in Cape May, known for its tasty American pub and tavern fare. The vibe is super casual—T-shirts and shorts fit right in. Conveniently located on the Washington Street Mall, the restaurant offers both indoor and outdoor seating. Inside, you'll find a lively bar and a spacious dining area. Outside, about a dozen tables let you soak up the mall’s energy while you eat. 

 Union Park 
Union Park is a Cape May gem that blends Old World elegance with breezy seaside charm. Nestled directly across from the ocean in the historic Hotel Macomber, this refined restaurant offers a memorable dining experience marked by romantic ambiance, spacious dining rooms, and antique touches. The menu showcases classic American cuisine with a sophisticated twist—artfully presented and crafted with fresh, locally sourced, farm-to-table ingredients.
Housed in a stately Victorian home, Union Park features a charming wraparound porch and two elegant dining rooms, each with a cozy fireplace.