Cape May Fish Market, Cape May, NJ:
A Restaurant Review
Cape May Fish Market
The Washington Street Mall
Cape May, NJ
Cape May Fish Market: Restaurant Highlights
Fare: Seafood
Price: Moderate
Food Quality: Sea food is fresh, locally caught, simply prepared without the more complex sauces and preparations, that overwhelm the taste of fresh seafood.
Service: Friendly and attentive.
Noise Level: Moderate - High
Dress: Casual
Recommended For: Diners who enjoy fresh, locally caught seafood, simply prepared without the more complex sauces and preparations.
Not Recommended For: Diners who prefer a wider selection of fried sea food; or the more upscale diners with a preference for the fine dining amenities.
Recommended Dishes: When available, Lobster Roll; Broiled Crab Cake Sandwich with Chipotle Sauce; Clam Chowder
Alcohol : BYOB, with local wines from Hawk Haven Vineyard available
The Cape May Fish Market is an excellent choice for visitors to the Washington Street Mall who want quality seafood in a relaxed, no-frills atmosphere for lunch or dinner.
The ambiance is modern and clean, featuring high-backed wooden booths lit by candles and walls adorned with vintage photographs of the historic concrete ships built near the end of the war, now resting off the coast of Cape May Point.
During warmer months, guests can enjoy outdoor dining on the pedestrian mall. If you're visiting during the summer, consider requesting outdoor seating to take in the lively atmosphere and indulge in some people-watching.
The waitstaff dress casually in T-shirts and black pants or shorts, adding to the laid-back vibe. Daily specials are displayed on a blackboard menu outside, while inside, two refrigerated cases showcase seafood available for purchase either raw or cooked for takeout.
The Fish Market stays true to simple, classic seafood preparations, offering grilled, deep-fried, or broiled options. They avoid overly complex sauces and focus on highlighting the fresh taste of the seafood. Portions are generous, so you might find yourself asking for a "doggie bag" to take home leftovers.
For dinner, if there's a wait, simply place your name on the list and enjoy a stroll around the mall while your table is prepared. The restaurant is family-friendly and offers a kids' menu, ensuring everyone in the group has an enjoyable experience.
Open year-round with seasonal hours, the Cape May Fish Market does not accept reservations, so plan accordingly.
(Updated: April 2025)
Our Restaurant Rating Criteria to Ensure Minimum Subjective Evaluation
