Black Horse Tavern - A Mendham, NJ Restaurant Review

Black Horse Tavern, Mendham, NJ
Black Horse Tavern
1 W. Main St. (Hilltop Rd.)
Mendham, NJ

Black Horse Tavern: Restaurant Highlights

Fare: Tavern style menu with many pub selections

Price: Expensive

Food Quality: Well executed tavern style menu.

Service: Friendly, attentive

Decor/Ambiance: Cozy, historic rustic.

Noise Level: In the Pub, high during peak times. Moderate in the main dining room.

Overall Rating: 2 1/2 stars

Note: Four-star Rating System from 1/2 Star =Poor to Four stars = Best in Class

Recommended For: Diners who seek upscale tavern experience in a picturesque, historic setting.

Not Recommended For: Diners who seek a casual BYOB family style, trendy atmosphere

Recommended dishes: When available, The Pub Ribeye served with Mashed Potatoes, Green Beans, Demi-Glaze; The Jumbo Crab Cakes served with Fresh Corn, Boiled Potatoes, Steamed Mussels, Green Beans, Old Bay Sauce; and The Stacked Baby Ribs served with BBQ Sauce, Cole Slaw, Baked Mac and Cheese.

Liquor: Full Bar Service. featuring a curated selection of wines, craft beers, and signature cocktails. The Mendham Mule, a twist on the classic Moscow Mule with hints of local honey, is a must-try.

Nestled in the heart of Mendham, NJ, the Black Horse Tavern offers a dining experience steeped in history and charm. This establishment, housed in a building dating back to 1742, combines rustic elegance with a modern menu, making it a favorite for both locals and visitors seeking a cozy yet sophisticated atmosphere.

The exposed wooden beams, stone fireplaces, and vintage décor create a warm, inviting environment. The soft lighting and classic country English furniture-inspired design provides an intimate setting, perfect for a romantic dinner or a quiet night out with friends.

During warmer months, the outdoor patio offers a delightful al fresco dining option, shaded by lush greenery.

The Black Horse Tavern's menu balances traditional tavern classics with inventive dishes. Its commitment to locally sourced ingredients shines through, and seasonal updates keep the offerings fresh and exciting.

The more informal pub is housed in two buildings. You can sit at the bar or at tables and be served a typical pub menu of burgers, steaks, sandwiches, and drinks by a working fireplace. The Pub is family-friendly but tends to have a high noise level during busy hours.

The other building is a more formal country inn with an expanded menu of traditional American food. The decor is a rustic country farmhouse with an early American history feel. Get a table by the working fireplace and enjoy a cozy dinner.

They have a piano bar every Friday evening and live Jazz on Saturday evenings.

They are Child friendly and offer valet parking

The Black Horse Tavern is open seven days a week for lunch & dinner.
They are also open for Sunday Brunch on Mother's and Father's Day, and on Thanksgiving with a special menu.

Updated April 2024