Barnacle Bill's, Rumson, NJ: A Restaurant Review
Barnacle Bill's
1 First St
Rumson, NJ
Restaurant Highlights
Fare: American Tavern
Price: Inexpensive - Moderate
Value: Excellent
Noise Level: Moderate - High
Excellent burgers, one of the best in the area.
Most of the other food on the menu while good, doesn't come up the the quality of their burgers.
Recommended For: Diners who enjoy good burgers or affordable food in a casual, unpretentious atmosphere.
Not Recommended For: Diners who prefer dining in a more formal upscale setting with an eclectic menu.
Recommended dishes: When available, The Classic Cheese Burger with American,Cheddar Sauce; The Fresh steamed lobster; and The Shrimp Scampi Baked in Garlic.
Liquor: Good selection of reasonably priced beers, wines and specialty cocktails. Bar scene is vibrant.
Nestled on the docks of the Navesink River, Barnacle Bill’s is a lively waterfront tavern where a laid-back nautical vibe meets hearty, wallet-friendly fare.
Designed to resemble a ship moored along the water, this bustling spot draws a vibrant mix of patrons—from families and boaters to stylish millennials and retirees—all united by a love for unpretentious fun and riverfront views.
The rustic, slightly weathered interior features a boisterous bar area lined with flat-screen TVs and a solid selection of beers on tap.
While the menu focuses on classic tavern staples (think crispy fries, pub sandwiches, and reliable seafood options), the star is undeniably their famed cheddar burger—a 10-ounce patty grilled over open flames behind the bar. Topped with a creamy, beer-infused cheddar sauce and served on a Kaiser roll with a side of potato chips, it’s hailed as one of Central Jersey’s best.
Though the food leans simple, prices are refreshingly reasonable.
Service is warm but no-frills, matching the relaxed atmosphere.
Come evenings or weekends, expect crowds and a wait for tables—proof of its local popularity.
Open daily for lunch and dinner, Barnacle Bill’s is a go-to for casual bites, cold brews, and that iconic burger with a side of sunset over the river.
(updated: February 2025)
Our Restaurant Rating Criteria to Ensure Minimum Subjective Evaluation
Navigating Red Bank, New Jersey: A Visitor's Guide!
Discover Red Bank's charm with a world class Arts Center entertainment venue, restaurants, and Victorian streetlamps.
Top Must-Visit Bars and Pubs in New Jersey!
Guide To The Best NJ Bars Featuring Sports Bars, Irish pubs, Country Bars, German Beer Gardens, and Singles Bars in NJ.
NJ Breakfast and Brunch: A Food Lover's Guide
Discover the "Best" Breakfast and Sunday Brunch Restaurants in NJ